Early one morning in the vibrant spring of Brooklyn, Drew, a New York City school teacher, sets out to collect items from her local Buy Nothing group. She braces herself for the very first pickup as she turns up at the doorstep of her old high school crush, Caleb. Surprised to find Caleb in a state of emotional turmoil, Drew impulsively invites him to join her for the rest of her pickups across the city. As they journey through Brooklyn’s diverse neighborhoods, the two friends navigate their way through awkward small talk, nostalgic reminiscence, and frank discussions about their current lives, leading them both to revelations about their past and future selves.