After Willem de Kooning’s painting Woman-Ochre is stolen in a daring mid-day heist, a decades-long mystery vexes law enforcement and the art world at large. In this quirky and introspective true crime documentary, director Allison Otto weaves together fascinating interviews with delightful reenactments starring Glenn Howerton of It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia. With surprising panache in its attention to detail, THE THIEF COLLECTOR uniquely investigates who stole the painting and what their motivations were for committing the crime...or crimes.