A young woman, Nikki, asks the guy she’s been dating if they’re exclusive, to which he responds with a yes, but a ‘polyamorous’ yes. Taken aback and confused, Nikki walks away to ponder the concept of polyamory and searches to identify her own feelings around the subject.

She seeks counsel from friends who have varying sexual orientations and identities. Roaming the streets of New York, she struggles to come to terms with what to do next. The following morning Nikki is offered a new perspective from her polyamorous roommate, which opens her mind to explore.